Discovery Reveals Fatal Flaw in Universal Translator

As Starfleet is about to make first contact with the mysterious Species 10C in Star Trek: Discovery, one of its most valuable devices may be useless.

WARNING: The following contains spoilers for Star Trek: Discovery Season 4, Episode 10, “The Galactic Barrier,” streaming now on Paramount+.

star trek has always been a sci-fi universe filled with extraordinary technology, from transporters to warp engines, but one of the most subtly useful advancements in Starfleet’s arsenal is the Universal Translator. Capable of deciphering virtually any verbal language instantly for those who wield it, the Translator has been a fixture in the star trek franchised since The original series and continues to be used by Starfleet into the 32nd century as revealed by Star Trek: Discovery. But as Captain Michael Burnham leads his crew on a vital diplomatic mission, a stark reminder of the translator’s glaring limitations has resurfaced.


The translator was introduced into the TOS Season 1 episode “Arena”, given to Captain Kirk and the captain of a rival Gorn ship while stranded on a remote planet by Metrons and ordered to fight to the death. The translator allowed Kirk and the Gorn to communicate with each other as the confrontation continued. A proper origin story for the Universal Translator was provided in Star Trek: Enterprise, with the translator described as an experimental device created by Starfleet and attached to communicators offering text translations to users. At the beginning of Discoverydecades later in the timeline and about a decade before TOStranslators became more common and were installed directly into most Starfleet communicators.


RELATED: Star Trek: Discovery Gives Burnham a Handler – With a Familiar Face


As the Discovery prepares to personally escort a Federation diplomatic delegation beyond the borders of the Milky Way to make official contact with the mysterious Species 10C, they are unsure how to properly communicate with the civilization responsible for creating the anomalies. devastating effects of dark matter. Since Species 10C remains a complete unknown, from physical appearance to level of sentience, Starfleet is unsure if civilization even uses verbal or written language to communicate, speculating that it may communicate entirely through non-human signals. verbs or pheromones. With this in mind, Starfleet decides to include linguistics scholars in the delegation to help facilitate accurate and complete communication when needed.


It’s not the first time in star trek story that Starfleet has faced limitations with its universal translator due to these types of linguistic complexities. The memorable Star Trek: The Next Generation The season 5 episode “Darmok” introduced a species that communicated entirely through cultural metaphors from its history. Although the translator could convert spoken words, the metaphors were lost on Captain Jean-Luc Picard until he learned the cultural references to understand. At time Star Trek: Lower Decksthe translators have been changed to account for this weakness, but not without the occasional hitch.


RELATED: Star Trek 4 Back On Track With Pine, Saldana, Urban, Cho, Quinto & Pegg


Picard to Darmok

With the Discovery having successfully emerged on the other side of the galactic barrier, leaving the Milky Way to reach its eerie destination, first contact and all the communication challenges that come with it are imminent. The Universal Translator facilitated diplomatic envoys across star trek story but, far outside the galaxy, this long-serving device may prove useless in the face of the unknown this time around. Species 10C is able to unleash a dark matter-powered singularity and deploy it on the far side of the cosmos, but this is no guarantee that first contact with the Federation will go as planned.


Created by Bryan Fuller and Alex Kurtzman, Star Trek: Discovery releases new episodes Thursdays on Paramount+.

KEEP READING: New York Times Crossword Puzzle Pits Star Wars vs. Star Trek – And They Both Win

chloe-sullivan-smallville

Smallville Star Tom Welling Addresses Allison Mack After Her Jail Sentence


About the Author